With many health systems end supportive medical treatments amid a crackdown from the current federal leadership, researchers and supporters state that the science of sex and gender is being inaccurately portrayed – with major repercussions for healthcare for all Americans.
Scientific Understanding Under Fire
Administration figures “lack a genuine grasp of the science at all,” noted Jey McCreight, head of Beyond X&Y and a doctoral degree holder in genetic science. McCreight added that using misinformation to limit healthcare access is a warning for all patients.
“These attacks are fundamentally coming from a wider effort to undermine science and expertise and truth,” they said.
Jess McLaughlin, an assistant professor of biology at the University of Alaska Anchorage, said: “These reductive views of the biology of sex are being used to back up transgender legislation and government rules.”
McLaughlin explained: “The research is being distorted in such a way to hurt people.”
New Federal Rules Restrict Treatment
The US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is implementing a new rule that would prohibit Medicaid and Medicare payments for gender-affirming care to patients under eighteen, including medications like puberty blockers and hormones. The public comment period for this policy recently concluded. The HHS would also bar federal programs from paying for this care.
Consequently, major clinics – including facilities in New York, Washington, and Utah – say they have ended their youth treatment programs, drastically reducing the access of transgender youth to appropriate care across the country.
Adult Treatment Faces Restrictions
Care for adults has faced new restrictions. The federal leadership recently stated it would end provision of transition-related care to transgender individuals in prisons. Jailed trans people will not have access to personal items that match their identity; anyone on hormone therapy will be forced to taper off. The new policy claims gender identity is “disconnected from biological reality” and “does not provide meaningful basis for identification”.
Wider Consequences for Medicine
Scientists have also said that restricting treatment based on distorted science could set a path for restricting other types of treatment, like abortion and vaccines.
“It’s not just targeting transgender individuals, it’s undermining women’s rights, bodily autonomy around abortion, disabled people, individuals on the spectrum,” one expert said. “It’s a larger movement to try to make people conform to what’s seen as an ideal, but that standard really comes from a particular ideology, not evidence-based fact.”
The HHS directive referred to supportive treatments as “sex-rejecting procedures”, a phrase that appears to have started with a faith-based organization. This rhetoric implies “a inflexible set of characteristics that are permanent,” the scientist said, “which is just not true.”
Complicated Biology of Sex
Global organizations caution about conflating identity with biology, which is usually defined by “bodily characteristics” like genetic markers, gene expression, chemical messengers, and anatomy.
The administration has had several stumbles in its attempt to establish a biological definition to restrict care.
An executive order aimed at “gender ideology extremism” and claimed that sex is “unchangeable”, with men and women determined by reproductive cells present “from fertilization”.
Those claims are flawed in several ways. When ova are first conceived, they are single-celled – meaning they cannot have separate reproductive cells. The structures that later become eggs begin to form months later in gestation. Sperm cells only mature during puberty.
The directive did not mention individuals with intersex traits, who have natural variations in chromosomes and physiology.
What is 'Sex'?
“A fundamental problem is: what exactly are we even talking about with ‘sex’? Is it about genetics? Often, that doesn't align,” McLaughlin said. “The majority of individuals actually have no idea what their XX or XY status are.”
While most people with XX chromosomes are women and male genetics are male, there are also variations like XX males, XY females, and different combinations like Klinefelter syndrome. “Science never really operates in clear-cut pairs,” McCreight said. “People have way more diversity than you would expect.”
Chromosomes give the body directions for development, McLaughlin said, adding: “Just like handing performers a script is the beginning, what you end up with can be very different... because there are many additional mechanisms that regulate and interpret that DNA code.”
Practical Consequences and Misinformation
During the HHS announcement, a senior official spoke about trans youth getting costly procedures. However, investigation could not find a single case of a patient under eighteen receiving that operation. It was also found that the overwhelming number of breast surgeries happen among non-transgender adolescents. For the transgender youth who need surgery, it is proven to be life-saving. Denying this care “will result in trans kids... at worst, possibly death,” McCreight said.
Healthcare providers may also fall prey to myths about sex and gender, creating more barriers for transgender healthcare. “You can get care that is not as effective or even damaging,” the professor said.
Transgender individuals have long faced difficulties accessing appropriate healthcare. “You hear about trans broken arm syndrome, where you go in for something obvious like a fracture, and people will quickly suggest, ‘Well, maybe it’s because you’re trans,’” McLaughlin said.
Broad Societal Impact
Misconceptions about science affect everyone, not just the transgender community. Cisgender men in the Veterans Affairs system have had trouble getting care for a serious illness because of the new HHS rules.
The administration is also considering further limits on abortion medications. “Even cis people should be concerned – what are the implications for their medical treatment when you have officials who don’t understand science that are making rules about these issues?” McCreight said.
“There is an erosion of evidence-based study as a entire field,” McCreight added. “The goal is discrediting knowledge. Because if you can’t get good information, they can basically put whatever propaganda they want forward.”